Title:
Batman: Child of Dreams (Click to go to the release post)
Writer(s):
Kia Asamiya (Click to see other books from this writer released on this site)
Review source:
Hilary Goldstein (Review 1) and
Origami (Review 2) (Don't click it, read the review here...
)
Review:
Review 1 - Batman goes Manga.
Batman is an international sensation and one of the world's most recognizable icons. With the growing popularity of manga in the US, it was only a matter of time before the two met. Kia Asamiya, best known for creating Silent Mobius and Steam Detectives, has been a long-time fan of the Dark Knight. Along with writer Max Allan Collins, Asamiya has attempted to bridge the gap between Western and Eastern comics with Batman: Child of Dreams with good success.
Drawn in classic manga style, but with a hint more reality than most manga action graphic novels, Child of Dreams wisely tangles Batman and Bruce Wayne in a conspiracy with ambitious journalists from Japan. Taking place both in Gotham and later in Japan, Child of Dreams introduces a new love interest for Bruce Wayne while asserting Batman's influence on other cultures. Batman is not just a revered hero in the states, but has rabid fans in other countries. In fact, it's Batman fandom that brings enterprising young reporter Yuko Yagi to Gotham City in hopes of an exclusive interview with the Dark Detective.
Yuko gets more than she bargained for with the trip. A group of pill-popping psychos are being mysteriously transformed into carbon-copies of Batman's greatest foes and Yuko is trapped in the middle. It will take the combined might and brains of Batman and Bruce Wayne to solve the mystery and keep Yuko from harm.
Child of Dreams is, in many ways, a throwback to the '80s Batman books where Bruce Wayne was almost as integral a part of the story as Batman. The delicate balancing act between dark avenger and womanizing entrepreneur makes for some good drama. Though the mystery culprit behind everything is as obvious and the enormous nose on Batman's face, Child of Dreams has everything you need from a Batman story -- a damsel in distress, conflicts for both Wayne and Batman, the Rogues Gallery and plenty of action.
While the exaggerated style may seem a bit odd for a Batman tale, the action scenes are top notch. If you can get over the fact that every character has a giant honker, Child of Dreams is a beautiful vision of the Batman in black and white. Don't expect a brand new take on Batman, Alfred or Commissioner Gordon. There are no ground-breaking developments, absurd behaviors or unique histories. This is classic Batman, but don't with a heavy magna influence. That may not make for the most original or greatest Batman tale ever, but it certainly makes for a good one.
Review 2 - I've never made a secret about my dislike for manga design. The only Japanese cartoon I really enjoy is Lupin the III and even then when it's more like a caper film than the Monkey Punch books.
Given my prejudice against manga, one must ask why on earth I would shell out twenty-five bucks for a manganized version of Batman. Do the math.
The book costs twenty-five bucks. It's three-hundred-and-fifty-two pages. If you were to copy this book at your local library, it would cost thirty-five dollars and twenty cents: not counting the cover that seems to depict an extraordinary painting of Michael Keaton as Batman, alone worth the price. DC is actually giving you more for your money not less or the near equivalent copy-rate.
Since the book was manga, I suspected post-Crisis continuity would be ignored. This meant I had a shot of actually seeing Batman in the book. This is a very attractive prospect for any Batman fan, and despite what some may believe, I am still a fan of the bat. It is my respect for the character that has forced my exile from his three alleged original universe titles.
Given that intense dislike of manga, I knew what I was in for when looking at the book. I was a little surprised to be able to go beyond the typical design scheme and recognize Kia Asamiya's talent for rendering a flow of panels that meshes quite admirably into a very appealing aesthetic.
Although, for instance Yuko, the young woman reporter, bears definite touches seemingly inherent in manga--a more abstract and homogenous face--the nuances to the way Asamiya depicts her body language combined with a strong, distinctive voice creates a unique character. Exaggeration of emotion, while present, Mr. Asamiya keeps minimized and largely isolated to villains under the influence, which to a certain degree rationalizes the reliance on the technique. None of the exaggeration reaches the level of super deformity.
Kia Asamiya does have an odd nose fetish--which has nothing to do with as far as I know manga tradition--running through his artwork, but once exposed, these large schnozzes on both men and women while not fading into the background become less distracting.
His Batman is an impressive figure both in shadow and fighting out in the light. Readers will be pleased to find Keatonesque touches to Asamiya's Dark Knight, but strangely these touches fade when he sketches Bruce Wayne; they almost seem like two different characters, at least in look.
Where Mr. Asamiya excels is in his characterization of Batman. He recognizes him as a deterrent to criminals, a figure of fear but also--and this is the most important part--a sane man who becomes a hero. MINOR SPOILERS AHEAD Indeed, it is Batman's heroism that serves as the basis for the villain's motive. The dénouement should interest any pre-Crisis Batman fan since it seems the Dark Knight is facing off against his distasteful post-Crisis metamorphosis. SPOILER Ends
This is a Batman who unlike the current model seems respectful toward women. Yuko comes to Gotham for a story but leaves Gotham with a new friend. Theirs is such a nice relationship and so refreshingly different from the typical post-Crisis relationships Batman has had which can be summarized as either get-out-of-my-city or she-should-have-ducked.
The shock is that DC did not charge more for the book especially given the work that was put into it and the value of the talent behind the project. Max Allan Collins the novelist of the Nathan Heller and Elliot Ness mysteries and no stranger to Batman translated the Japanese. Kia Asamiya has become an American hit with his attention to the X-Men.
None of these names really mattered to me though after reading the story. The draw is in the characters and watching Batman take down an evil that has built up around him. Batman, Yuko and the villain in fact assume the roles of knight, princess and dragon without losing characterization, depth or strength. In this way, Batman: Child of Dreams has the feel of an epic and something special that deserves to be a hardcover and on your bookshelf.
More info:
Writer: Kia Asamiya
Letters & art: Dan Nakrosis
Translation: Max Allan Collins