Hi! I thought, as I have read both and am very familiar with both stories, I could share my opinion!
Firstly, are we talking about the books or the movies?
If we're talking movies, I think Divergent wins hands down, because it's more realistic... Like, the Capitol, in the HG movies just looked ridiculous. I mean, yeah it's supposed to but... idk it made the HG less down to earth so to speak. Also, the HG are a very silent movie series, because Katniss has a lot of internal monologues/speech/thoughts, and I guess I didn't really like that?
If we're talking books, then... oohh that's hard, because Allegiant was definitely... unexpected. Actually, yeah. HG wins bookwise. I might not like how the HG tril truned out (i.e. basically it was all a propoganised revolution, it didn't have the herione out there doing the nitty-gritty stuff), but at least Katniss had a unique and definite character. Tris' character was strongly written at first, and the Divergent tril COULD have had a great character development plot over the 3 books, but near the end, I just felt like Tris was losing her touch. As was Tobias. I just felt like Tris' character was gradually devolving into a whiny, groany mess and that Tobias basically became her parent. Nonetheless, no one can JUST.... squish FourTris like that, so in the end I re-wrote the ending.
Firstly, are we talking about the books or the movies?
If we're talking movies, I think Divergent wins hands down, because it's more realistic... Like, the Capitol, in the HG movies just looked ridiculous. I mean, yeah it's supposed to but... idk it made the HG less down to earth so to speak. Also, the HG are a very silent movie series, because Katniss has a lot of internal monologues/speech/thoughts, and I guess I didn't really like that?
If we're talking books, then... oohh that's hard, because Allegiant was definitely... unexpected. Actually, yeah. HG wins bookwise. I might not like how the HG tril truned out (i.e. basically it was all a propoganised revolution, it didn't have the herione out there doing the nitty-gritty stuff), but at least Katniss had a unique and definite character. Tris' character was strongly written at first, and the Divergent tril COULD have had a great character development plot over the 3 books, but near the end, I just felt like Tris was losing her touch. As was Tobias. I just felt like Tris' character was gradually devolving into a whiny, groany mess and that Tobias basically became her parent. Nonetheless, no one can JUST.... squish FourTris like that, so in the end I re-wrote the ending.